| Champion | Won | Lost | Days Held | Notes |
| The Gift of Gab Gabby Ortiz | 6/8/2024 | | | |
| Kaia McKenna | 4/13/2024 | 6/8/2024 | 57 | |
| The Unwilting Tatiana | 10/14/2023 | 4/13/2024 | 183 | |
| Valentina Vasquez | 12/18/2021 | 10/14/2023 | 666 | Valentina attacked The Unforgiven Salem before the match to keep her from the triple threat match, but with the referee tending to Tatiana, Salem attacked Valentina before sending her back into the ring for Tatiana to pick up the victory. |
| Karen BamBam | 1/11/2020 | 12/18/2021 | 210* | [CDC guidelines as a result of COVID-19 shut down all sports in New York March 2020 to July 2021. Reign to include active dates only.] |
| Ariela Nyx | 2/19/2019 | 1/11/2020 | 327 | Defeated Eris Spiral in tournament finals |
| Vacated | 1/19/2019 | | | Masha Slamovich stripped of championship |
| Masha Slamovich | 9/22/2018 | 1/19/2019 | 120 | |
| Kris Statlander | 6/23/2018 | 9/22/2018 | 92 | 2x champion
(469 combined)
Falls count anywhere match restarted by Commissioner Fulton |
| Sam L’Eterna | 6/23/2018 | 6/23/2018 | <1 | Sam L’Eterna won the championship in a match after double teaming Statlander with partner Antoinette Marie. |
| Kris Statlander | 6/10/2017 | 6/23/2018 | 379 | |
| Karen Q | 4/30/2016 | 6/10/2017 | 407 | |
| Nikki Addams | 6/6/2015 | 4/30/2016 | 330 | |
